Locke’s Religious Epistemology and Its Critics
- Philosophy
- Publisher: Routledge
- Published: 2025
FritzSearch.com earns a commission on purchases made through Bookshop.org links.
Publisher's Description
This book offers a sustained defense of Locke’s religious epistemology. It puts Locke into conversation with leading figures in contemporary religious epistemology and shows that Locke’s views are more plausible than many philosophers of religion and epistemologists realize. Locke has become the villain in contemporary religious epistemology. In recent years, Locke has often been singled out and criticized for insisting that religious belief requires evidence and for failing to provide adequate evidence that would support rational belief in God and Christianity. This book defends a broadly Lockean religious epistemology. The author argues that we need evidence for religion and that there is good evidence supporting belief in God and Christianity. He discusses Locke’s views on the evidence from natural theology, religious experience, the testimony of miracles, and scripture. In each chapter, the author contrasts Locke’s view on a type of evidence with one of his critics: Michael Bergmann, David Hume, Alvin Plantinga, Richard Swinburne, and Linda Zagzebski. At the end of each chapter, the author shows how a Bayesian analysis of evidence can support Locke’s evidence for religious belief, specifically a belief in Christianity. This defense of Locke’s position shows how his religious epistemology continues to be relevant in contemporary debates. Locke’s Religious Epistemology and Its Critics is a historically informed contribution to religious epistemology. It will appeal to researchers and graduate students working in epistemology, philosophy of religion, and history of philosophy.
Endorsements (3)
“Locke’s Religious Epistemology and Its Critics is an important contribution both to Locke scholarship and to the philosophy of religion. Anyone interested in these subjects will be richly rewarded by engaging with Rockwood’s book.”
“For several decades, the philosophical discussion of rational religious belief has been dominated by externalist accounts of religious belief – accounts that effectively change the subject. Nate Rockwood’s new book returns to the evidentialist tradition and addresses the questions we really wanted to ask, questions about evidence and rationality, and it does so with a clear and critical view of the arguments that had persuaded so many to abandon Locke’s appealingly simple approach. The result is a lucid work full of both historical and technical insight. I hope it opens the door for more to follow.”
“Rockwood examines central issues in the analytic philosophy of religion, with a particular focus on religious epistemology. Drawing on his expertise in epistemology, philosophy of religion, and Locke scholarship, he offers a compelling case for Locke’s evidentialism. Meticulous in its textual analysis, the book will appeal to historians of philosophy, while its engagement with contemporary religious epistemology shows how Locke’s views on evidentialism, natural theology, and Christian faith remain relevant today.”
See something wrong on this page? Report a problem