Skip to main content
Cover of Willing to Die

Willing to Die

Martyrdom in the Mennonite Imagination

  • History & Biography
  • Publisher: Fortress Press (Augsburg Fortress)
  • Published: 2026

FritzSearch.com earns a commission on purchases made through Bookshop.org links.

Publisher's Description

As the Reformation spread through Europe, thousands of individuals faced imprisonment, exile, and even execution for the crime of permitting themselves to be re-baptized. In the eyes of the established Church authorities--whether Catholic, Lutheran, or Reformed--these dissenters were justly condemned as dangerous heretics. But to their fellow Anabaptists, they were martyrs, reliving the persecution suffered by the early Church. Willing to Die explores the relationship between the figures of the martyr and the heretic in relations to the early Anabaptist movement, illuminating how the promoters of believers' baptism could be understood by their fellow Christians as earnest advocates of the restoration of the church of the apostles, or as a seditious threat to the common peace. As recent scholarship on early Christian martyrdom has shown, the fact of death alone has never sufficed to make someone a martyr. Rather, martyrs are created by being commemorated as such by a community. From the earliest days of Christianity, one community's martyr could be another's heretic. By compiling martyrologies that included some executed Anabaptists and excluded others, surviving Anabaptists in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries joined a centuries-long intra-Christian debate in which the commemoration of the special dead define the boundaries of legitimate beliefs and practices of the True Church.


Endorsements (3)

“This is the book that the champions and the critics of Anabaptist martyrs don’t know they need. Think of this as “higher criticism” for the Martyrs’ Mirror. Otto situates the Mennonite martyr tradition into the long history of Christian veneration of “the special dead” and shows specific influences on Dutch Mennonite martyr books. Willing to Die goes both deep and wide, examining ancient, medieval, and Reformation views on persecution, suffering, saints, providential history, and baptism that should inform specialists and general readers alike. The book even functions as an immensely readable and lively refresher of Swiss and Dutch Anabaptist history through the lens of persecution and martyrdom.”

Mary S. Sprunger

“In this study about Mennonites and martyrdom, Jennifer Otto brilliantly weaves into her narrative the various martyrological traditions of the ancient, medieval, and early modern worlds. The result is an expansive and thoroughly contextualized analysis that brings to the foreground elements of surprise and intrigue. Otto’s work is an excellent resource for scholars and provides ample material for those asking questions regarding the scope and limits of religious commitment and resolve.”

Karl Koop

“Willing to Die is a riveting exploration of how Anabaptists raided the libraries of their persecutors. Jennifer Otto shows that the Mennonite tradition of martyrdom was never a thing apart but was built, story by story, from the same ancient Christian materials that Catholics and Protestants claimed as their own. This is confessional history at its best—learned, lucid, and alert to the ironies that arise when rival churches fight over who gets to claim the very special dead.”

Kyle Smith

See something wrong on this page? Report a problem