Skip to main content

Hadley Arkes

Books Endorsed by Hadley Arkes

Did America Have a Christian Founding?

Ethics, Culture & Social Issues

“A critically important work, Mark Hall’s latest book demonstrates that a large number of America’s Founders held deep Christian faith, and applied their beliefs to the Nation’s foundational documents, speeches, and Constitutional provisions. Relying on original sources and texts, and written for the academic and the nonacademic alike, this book is for anyone who is interested in answering for themselves, Did America have a Christian founding?” “As Mark Hall reminds us, the Bible did not provide a manual for the Constitution as a structure of governance. But the Jewish–Christian tradition provided the deep moral premises that underlay the Constitution, for it provided an account of the ‘human person’ and the rightful and wrongful ways for human beings to be governed. As Lincoln would say, ‘nothing stamped with the Divine image and likeness was sent into the world to be trodden on, and degraded, and imbruted by its fellows.’ What Christianity confirmed was that human beings were ‘rights-bearing beings.’ And that sense of things would underlie the claim to all of our natural and Constitutional rights, from the grand to the prosaic. It would encompass our right not to have our lives taken, our freedom restricted, or our earnings and property taken in a lawless way, without justification. Mark Hall offers a bracing corrective to those scholars and writers who have somehow failed to notice the Jewish–Christian moral premises that thread through the Constitution. And he brings the insight that will also come as news to them: that our tradition of religious pluralism did not spring from a ‘secular’ understanding that began simply by denying that any particular religion has a plausible claim to truth. That pluralism, and religious tolerance, sprang rather from our religious tradition. It was anchored in the understanding that creatures of reason should come to an understanding of God through their reflection and reason, not through coercion. And that is not a moral understanding that comes along with just anything that calls itself ‘religion.’ The American understanding of religious freedom made room for people making their way to God in their own way, but as Hall points out, ‘religious’ freedom made no sense if a new view of religion managed to dispense with God. Not just any local god, but the one recognized at the very beginning in the Declaration of Independence: the Author of the laws of nature, including the moral laws, and the Creator who endowed us with rights. The irony is that a regime that began with that understanding of God was more likely to protect the freedom of Buddhists and Unitarians, and in its large nature, even atheists.”

Books Authored or Contributed to by Hadley Arkes

No books by this person in our catalog yet.

See something wrong on this page? Report a problem